The Best Ice Cream Sandwich Recipe

If We have Bob Ross for painting, we have John for cooking. Absolutely delightful and soothing to watch you cook and make such wonderful recipes 😊

When my brother and I were kids my family didn't have much money. Our mom couldn't afford real ice cream sandwiches so we made them ourselves using graham crackers, vanilla ice cream, and wax paper. They weren't real ice cream sandwiches but to us they were perfect.

I've made these for two different summer parties. People were blown away with how delicious they are! I wrapped each one in parchment paper and tied with a colorful baking twine.

I was always hesitant about clicking on his channel. I already had my favourites. Now I am going through his the archive of missed episodes. He clearly tells all the subtleties of all his recipes, which I like.

This was a great recipe! But I’m going to mention two things if anyone decides to try following along themselves. 1) Lay out the 2 eggs and unsalted butter immediately. They need to be room temperature and the video doesn’t mention them until you’ve gotten to the point you need them. 2) If you need to put your cookie back in the oven to soften the butter holding the parchment, let it cool again. If you try flipping it right away it will fall apart. Either let it cool again or extend the parchment paper to give you a way to safely pull the cookie out. It’s a lot less stressful that way.

I CAN NOT wait to make these. I always loved ice cream sandwiches as a kid. OMG, I'm so excited!

he has the luckiest kids (and husband) in the world, so many tasty treats! I'll definitely be making these

You are an amazing teacher! I absolutely LOVE your kind voice and instruction on making the most difficult recipes doable for me…the non-professional!! Thank you for share your knowledge with all of us!!

Growing up, my mom would make is ice cream sandwiches using ice cream and hamburger buns.

I love it when I watch someone make a recipe and I have all the ingredients...even the sprinkles! My kids will love it. They most definitely won't be as neat as yours but hopefully just as delicious

My daughter loves you and now we are currently making these, waiting on the “mega cookie to cool” I rewatch to make sure I don’t miss anything. And yes… oh the smells 😊🤤

I've done this. Brought them to work in a cooler with dry ice. It was a fun project that everybody liked.

Very nice recipie John! They looks amazing! Have a nice day and good week! 👍👏🍫🍫🍫

Thank you for being/bringing such a pleasant joy to a stressful day!

These children are BLESSED

I have been looking for this recipe and here it is. John you are a mind reader my dear. Thank you!

These look soooooo good....my mom showed me long time ago when cakes don't turn out to place over burner. Just move around all the surface quickly. Fast and works.

Your kids much love it every time you make a video! Thank you for the clear directions.

My mom loves ice cream sandwiches. I always thought they were pretty good, but I’m excited to try these tmr. Food always tastes delicious when it’s the fruits of your own labor

I can’t wait to try these. We buy the store brand all the time, but these are going to be a special treat! Thank you John!