History Buffs: Alexander Revisited

2,692,603
2,623
Published 2016-03-10
Well this is a first one guys. A historically accurate film that sucks. Now remember this is just my opinion but hopefully you will understand my reasons why I don't like Alexander.


SUPPORT HISTORY BUFFS ON PATREON
www.patreon.com/HistoryBuffs

HISTORY BUFFS MERCH!
history-buffs-shop.fourthwall....

● Follow us on Facebook: www.facebook.com/HistoryBuffsLondon
● Follow us on Twitter: twitter.com/HistoryBuffs_


Alexander is a 2004 epic historical drama film based on the life of Alexander the Great. It was directed by Oliver Stone, with Colin Farrell in the title role. The film was an original screenplay based in part on the book Alexander the Great, written in the 1970s by the University of Oxford historian Robin Lane Fox. Upon its release, the film received generally favourable reviews by European critics. Negatively received in the United States, it grossed over $167 million worldwide against a $155 million budget.

All Comments (21)
  • @HistoryBuffs
    I would like to give my thanks to youtube.com/@AnimeWins/about for helping me fight the copyright claims in this review. If any of you are content creators and get hit by claims as well and are within fair use, he'll help you fight them and win. Just reach out to him through his business email. He guided me through every step of the process and has won hundreds of claims over the years.
  • @garybusey1772
    Nick, as a greek man I can inform you that the reason why everyone is yelling in the movie is because greeks yell all the time
  • @ryanyeager3258
    HBO should make a TV series out of the life of Alexander the Great. That be the best way to tell his story.
  • @dissodatore
    the worst thing about the "Oedipus Complex" is that in the story of Oedipus, he marries his mother unknowingly, and the complex named for him is about knowingly desiring your mother. talk about punishing an innocent!
  • @user-xf2wi2ed3l
    I think they overdid the whole 'Zeus is your father' thing in the movie. It was actually very common for great leaders to claim that they were descended of the gods. Julius Caesar claimed to be descended directly from Aeneas and Aphrodite. All great heroes from mythology were said to be descended from the gods (e.g. Hercules), so thats why a lot of real people from that time did too.
  • @billaros1338
    Give some credit to his father, he was a rare military genius. He revolutionized warfare with the use of sarisa, a 6 meter spear and a great phalanx formation.
  • @bennh3181
    In defense of Oedipus from the play, the character the complex was based on, he had absolutely no idea the man he killed was his father and the woman he married his mother and when he found out, he gouged his own eyes out and went to live out the rest of his life as a hermit in exile...so...it wasn't like Oedipus actually even wanted to sleep with his mother.
  • 15:00 the reason why he was saying their names wasn’t for us to remember them IMO, it just showed how Alexander appealed to his men by naming them directly and attaching qualities to their names
  • alexander needed to be a trilogy (his youth, his ascendence, his late years)
  • Alexander didn't revolutionise ancient warfare by himself, you have to give Phillip at least some credit for that.
  • @ZergrushEddie
    “Treat me, Alexander, the way a King treats another King” is probably the most badass surrender in human history.
  • The historical advisor for this film (according to my Greek history lecturer at least) apparently absolutely hero-worshipped Alexander and waived his fee in return for getting to take part in one of the cavalry charges, which may explain the rather sparkling portrayal of Alexander's character in the film
  • @StunnzBADGER
    apparently there is a story where alexander crossing the desert came to a small oasis that only had enough water to fill one cup. It was given to alexander who poured it out in front of his men to say that he would suffer with his men instead of take the special treatment. May be just a story but I think when it came to his army, Alexander was genuinely honored to lead them and cared for them deeply. I think crossing the desert was more of an ego move to prove that it could be done, only by him. Great vid!!
  • @saltymisfit6566
    Well at least the casting for Alexander's mother was right on. I mean no one really pulls off insanely hot & Batshit insane like Angelina Jolie
  • @nerfherder2
    Alexander should be a drama/series like HBO Rome.
  • @savsal2603
    "Everyone is shouting in this movie" I mean.... us Greeks are VERy very very loud people... could be historical accuracy lmao
  • @Gomez1915
    Angelina Jolie wasn’t acting. That’s how she is in real life
  • @T2266
    Well, if your mother looks like Angelina Jolie in her early 30s...
  • @lmnisop5516
    If Alexander's accent bothers you so should the fact that he's speaking English.
  • @pablosoto4422
    Listen closely in the death scene, Alexander whispers something and the generals are trying to decipher what he means. Cratistos meaning “to the strongest” or was he referring to his general Craterus, that he was leaving his empire to him.