Ranking Every Van Der Linde Gang Member By Importance To The Gang

Published 2024-03-14
Twitch: www.twitch.tv/rdtlgames

NONE OF THIS FOOTAGE IS MY OWN.

Today, I am going to rank every Red Dead Redemption 2 in a tierlist, starting from the worst chapters, and going all the way to the best chapters.

This is just my opinion, so put yours in the comments and let's debate!

All Comments (21)
  • Anyone else find it hilarious how he talks about jack like he ISNT a 4 year old💀💀💀
  • @adamturner749
    I'd argue Kieran does more in the back ground than is often noticed or realised. He keeps the horses fit and healthy and cared for and I'd say that's a very important task for the gang.
  • Bill planned the only successful bank robbery in the whole game, definitely he shouldn’t be that low.
  • ranking strauss above arthur breaks my heart in a way i didn’t know was possible
  • @Fighterx356
    This channel should be named after your hate for Jack. Every video is blasting Jack, and i am here for it
  • @mrchungus128
    Arthur’s contributions are in the thousands in just the time we see the gang, and he was with the gang for many years before that. He definitely raked in more money than Strauss and also is the top gunslinger for the gang which is why he’s in ever single robbery in the game, he’s easily number 3
  • @j1fferson
    Kieran was important he was good with horses and was the one feeding, cleaning and caring about them for the gang. He basically was the gangs stable hand/horsekeeper...
  • @TrapDeacon
    It seems like Arthur was known as the best gunslinger in the gang. In several mission, members say Arthur is a better shot than them
  • @rpggamer323
    Wdym Tilly,Karen and Mary-Beth doesn't provide they literally do the laundry, dishes, cleaning up of the gang Edit:Btw you said that susan gets angry at them for not working that only happens if you do not upgrade the camp and chapter 6 Edit 2:How tf is Arthur number 5 like i am not even gonna argue about it...
  • @Reverse_Goat
    24 Jack (Cause he's a kid) 23 Reverend (drains resources) 22 Molly (Does nothing) 21 Mary Beth (Was in a stagecoach mission, Is a good writer) 20 Tilly (Gives one bank robbery tip to Arthur but in the gang she does nothing) 19 Abigail (was there in the Saint Denis bank job and takes care of Jack) 18 Uncle (Can handle a gun lol) 17 Karen (Did some digging on the valentine bank robbery and can handle a gun) 16 Kieran (Can handle a gun and takes care of horses) 15 Bill (I mean he was involved in many of the gangs involvement but he's kinda dumb) 14 Sadie (She helped the gang after shady belle) 13 Sean (Debatable with Sadie but since he was with the gang longer he's a bit higher. He was involved more) 12 Lenny (Did help in finding shady belle) 11 Trelawny (Helps the gang with many helpful stuff. Arthur does say the moment they think he's not useful, he does something useful) 10 Susan (is like the mother of the gang ig) 9 Micah (Was kinda Dutchs 2nd man after Arthur got sick. Even before chap 6 considering he wasnt a member for long Dutch did use him quite a lot more than other characters) 8 Charles (Similar to Micah, Dutch used Charles a bit more than the other members but Charles does a bit more in the camp) 7 Jaiver (Great gunslinger, been with the gang for a while and saved John) 6 John (I mean he's one of the gang members who's been for a longer time. He also plans the train robbery, sheep deal and the gray horses) 5 Leopard (Dutch literally asks Arthur to meet Leopard. He does say it gives a lot of money. He's the only one who provides money in a legal way.) 4 Pearson (Camp cook) 3 Hosea (Gives a lot of wisdom) 2 Arthur (Brute of the gang) 1 Dutch (Literally connected to all of the gang members activities.) Imo. Thoughts?
  • @josemedina1805
    Imma be honest... Arthur should be number one or at least number 2 behind Hosea because he is the guy who actually gets things done. Even if you count only the canonical things he does to contribute, he does or is involved with pretty much at least 40%-50% or so of everything the gang does to make money or fix problems. The dude even keeps this up while slowly dying to a terminal desease. He hard carries the gang ngl
  • @Oxycodone__
    Hosea was the thing keeping control of Dutch. After his death everything fell apart.
  • @Thrilltime69
    Kieran does shit for the horses. Idk if its just one time thing or I saw him clean my horse
  • @angelserenade
    Seems like Abigail is the one in charge whenever there are members that needed medical attention, just like when Davey was injured, and eventually died, she's the first to take a look. When John was saved from the mountains, she also nursed him to health. She had also participated in Saint Denis bank heist (quite a crazy plan, they should have gone with Karen tbh) Kieran, even if you dont take him to missions, he takes care of the horses of the gang. Like he's the stable hand. Lenny helps with the missions or scouting of the gang. He also participated in train robbery and even gave you the tip of a gang hold weapons for sale. His role is pretty much like Bill, Javier and Charles.