this is just mean & cruel for no reason | I-LAND2 SHADIEST MOMENTS ep3

honestly the judges comments might seem harsh, but I agree with most of what they said, they were quite constructive!!

They actually spoke the truth about Kang Jiwon, since the audition stage I wondered how she got into the show, girl has nothing

honestly… the judges really haven’t been THAT bad so far. when the panorama team was doing their midpoint evaluation & couldn’t hit the notes i was fully preparing for the judges to scream at them then expect them to be able to sing an entire key higher by the end of the week yet to my surprise… they completely understood, didn’t get mad at all and lowered the key to fit the girls vocal range better. it should be the bare minimum but it’s not so it was nice to see mentors actually being realistic with the girls & actually trying to help them

i'm literally confused why they would scout girls like yeeun and that one terrible singer in bad boy 😭 like if y'all don't want untalented people then why are they here

Tell them to choose a partner and be all besties with each other but don't tell them you will be competing against each other until later. So cruel.

FUKO LOOKED LIKE A RED VELVET MEMBER IN THE PERFORMANCE, UM JIWON, LINGLING AND FUKO SLAYED THE DAY

2:19" nam yuju bursts into tars after losing her part " is she supposd to b happy aftr going from main rapper to a 6 second part? but she still workd hard and slayd that 6 secs

I see lingling has a really large fanbase but I don't really see much potential in her?? Idk on which base they like her

Giving them panorama for like their second test was EVIL. Just straight up diabolical atp…

the bad boy dance break gave me runext flashbacks

I think for panorama the main vocalist part should have been given to two people. They are going to push this girl until she makes a mistake and just start critizing her. Most of their comments are just how pretty the girls are. Ok ok I get it everyone there is pretty and cute. Stage presence and making gestures is a talent but not visuals. Them telling that one girl that she is short. Sorry but if I am 1,55m and am standing next to someone who is 1,70m I will look short no matter what I do. The only judge I like so far is the strict guy.

personally think yuju literally is the combination of soojin and garam

I feel sorry for Kang Jiwon yeah she's bad but her skills can develop! the unecessary hate is not it

as others have said, panorama was a set up. Its super high and you need multiple strong vocalists. The production team was like fk that group that gets that one.

The judges are only focusing on visuals and it's irritating me

YOU DIDDDD NOTTTT just pull that Requiem for a Dream reference omgggg my eyes 🤦🏻‍♀️😂😂😂😂😂😂i want to unsee that lmaooooo

I feel so bad for yeeun but the judge did not lie. I mean, she has potential, but needs a LOT more training.

some of the comments from the judges were lowkey kinda harsh and borderline offensive, even if they were needed. this episode also solidified who i was and wasn't going to vote for, if that makes sense?

The amout of haters each member get just bc their selected member dont get attention like they want...yeeun, lingling, mai they deserve to debut!

sujung and yui were my favorite performers in whistle yes!