The story of the orthodox Jews that oppose Israel | Rabbi Elhanan Beck | UNAPOLOGETIC

226,840

6,708 0

2024-04-17に共有

Rabbi Elhanan Beck has lived outside of Israel since he was three years old, this is despite the fact that his family lineage in what he calls “Palestine” goes back seven generations.

Beck stands with what he says are the vast majority of Orthodox Jews who strongly oppose Israel. Their reason: The Jewish religious principle that Jews need to live in exile until the “peaceful” arrival of the messiah, and because of the “oppression” and “brutality” that Israel is built upon.

In this in-depth interview Rabbi Elhanan speaks about Judaism, Israel, Zionism, and 'red cows', and he reacts to what he openly calls Israel’s “genocide” in Gaza.

00:00 Intro
00:56 Rabbi early life and connection to the holocaust
04:41 Life in England and anti-Israel activism
09:02 Judaism as a religion vs a race or state
12:53 The idea of Jewish people being in exile and what it means
13:30 What is Zionism
15:49 Zionism and Judaism - compatibility
22:20 The Rabbi's perception of non-religious Jews
28:28 The Problem with Zionism
32:27 Orthodox Jews and the state of Israel
35:27 How Zionism adopted some Orthodox Rabbis
38:27 The Orthodox Rabbi's who support Israel?
40:27 Jewish persecution in Europe
42:27 Jews who live in the muslim world
44:27 How Mossad created a rift between Jews and Muslim Arabs
46:27 Jewish rabbi speaks about no anti-semitism in Iran
48:27 What about having a fair and just Jewish state
52:49 Why some Orthodox Rabbi's support Zionism - protection vs belief
58:49 Isreal is the most unsafe place for Jewish people
01:03:54 Media doesn't show Orthodox Jews who are anti-zionist
01:04:59 taking a moment to break fast
01:06:33 Did he Rabbi always want to be a Rabbi
01:07:55 When did the state of Israel first hurt you?
01:09:12 How would you feel if you were in Gaza
01:11:55 Palestinian relationship with Jews
01:15:15 The Rabbi's feelings on Hamas and October 7th
01:18:15 Why Israel as a state cannot succeed
01:21:27 The red cows and the messiah
01:26:55 What is the messiah
01:28:00 thoughts on Isreal's response to October 7th
01:30:46 What would you say to a Palestinian child?

Subscribe to our channel: ow.ly/AVlW30n1OWH

Subscribe to MEE Telegram channel to stay up to date: t.me/MiddleEastEye_TG

Middle East Eye Website: middleeasteye.net/
Follow us on TikTok: www.tiktok.com/@middleeasteye
Follow us on Instagram: instagram.com/MiddleEastEye
Like us on Facebook: facebook.com/MiddleEastEye
Follow us on Twitter: twitter.com/MiddleEastEye

コメント (21)

@jimmyromano4525 1ヶ月前

This man eloquently demonstrates how anti-Zionism is not anti-semitism. Much respect.
@mumsow 1ヶ月前

A true Palestinian Jew.
@ahanadiri5330 21日前

This rabbi is an outstanding example of Jewish clarity 🤍
@hawkeyeeagle5280 12日前

"I will go back to the Holy Land when I get my Palestinian passport." Now that is powerful.
@deenadia288 1ヶ月前

Bless this Rabbi. He’s so patient with the interviewer
@user-bd7hn3dd3v 28日前

This brother is more jewish than most jews more muslim than most muslims and more human than most humans. May allah guide him ❤ Thank you rabbi. You stand with us and we stand with you.
@skanderzenaidi9342 21日前

Dear Mr. the interviewer, I think, as you can read in the comments, we all agree with this wonderful and CRYSTAL CLEAR man of God and disagree with your way of conducting this interview. Next time keep your suppositions for yourself and let the host speak please. May God protect all the good hearted people on earth regardless of their faith. And as a muslim I just want to restate that: WE LOVE OUR JEWISH BROTHERS and NOTHING not the evil doings of the Gen0cidal stAte of IZrAel nor anything else will never change a thing about it.
@leannefranson1198 21日前

Brilliant man. Thank you for having him on. I'm not religious at all, and he makes perfect sense about his beliefs, about what would bring safety for Jews, and peace.
@fahdabdelhalim 21日前

As a muslim I find myself closer to this rabbi more than the Muslim interviewer who knows nothing
@xCoolverine 1ヶ月前

Much respect to the Rabbi
@mohamedabid9936 21日前

The rabbi has better understanding of islam than the interviewer.
@bobbymercer9789 21日前

As a Muslim I highly highly highly respect this rabbi, I wish him nothing but the best and protection! We as Muslims must protect this man at all costs! Huge respect to you brother
@moonlight-lz9qt 21日前

The interviewer was painful to listen to. He tried to push Zionism to the Rabbi who clearly explained that Zionism is against Judaism 😩
@gotcha4054 1ヶ月前

A Rabbi with a beautiful soul. We humans must co-exist and love each other for we are all children of God.
@milena-with-love464 21日前

I adore this Rabbi! He has a righteous mind and a pure soul
@RusIanRoy 21日前

We need more Jews like Rabbi Elhanan, Champion of Truth.
@user-hr2bk4vg1e 21日前

This man is very wise, very kind, very honest. This what you call a true bleiver. Allah bless him and protect to tell the truth. May Allah reward him for his good work.
@aiesyahsyahirah4717 21日前

I got goosebump when he said he will go back to holyland once he got Palestinian passport.
@hattiejaz52 21日前

“7th of October didn’t happen just six months ago, it’s happening for 75 years ago.” Rabbi Elhanan Beck is a beacon of beauty ~ as evidenced by his compassionate eyes. What a gift and pleasure to hear him share his thoughts. 🙏🏼 🙏🏼🙏🏼🕊️🕊️🍉🍉🍉🕊️🕊️
@user-winterdarkness 21日前

A beautiful interview from this Palestinian man. Very interesting . An eye opener to me. It was beautiful when he explained that he looks at the world through religious eyes and not through any personal bias or personal thought. It is something we should all be doing humbly and with an open mind. As a Muslim it made me feel humble and my mind more open to learn more about the Jewish faith. ❤