The Greatest Buggy Theory Ever Made

Clowns spread joy Buggy is a boy ∴ Buggy is Joyboy

Buggy being Rocks' son would just be another one of Oda's gags with a ridiculously long buildup it's very likely LOL 😂

Theory: “You’ll die if you go on that Island” Disease that Usopp lied about is real with Mihawk and Crocodile catching it when Cross Guild gets close to luaghtale. Buggy doesn’t continue because he afraid to not have his muscle with him to beat the other pirate crews after it, his subordinates see it as Buggy caring more for his crew then the treasure, and Buggy is seen as the one who could have gotten the One Piece first but didn’t like White Beard. Making Buggy the White Beard to Luffy’s Roger.

The Drake picture when you talk about Buggy being a Liar .. LOL.

The mention of "not only luffy but buggy was also on Roger's execution platform.." that hit deeeep.

he will split atoms with his awakening. The ultimate Buggy-Ball. Buggyheimer-Ball

Buggy D. Clown has the same incurable disease as Go D. Usopp, the "I can't go to that island" disease which is why he will never reach Laugh Tale. The illness seems to be common among extremely powerful entities.

That Impel Down look is Buggy’s best look imo

"nami was an orphan and later made an orphan again" jeeez

Personally, I think it'd be far more charming if Buggy's parents were alive and the absolute nicest people.

we are SO up

If Buggy can't go on to Laughtale because of illness due to magnetism the Cross Guild would have to pick up a hell of a doctor. And didn't Law just lose a serious battle against Blackbeard? And hasn't the Cross Guild made a habit of recruiting ex-Warlords? Just imagine the scene of Buggy in a wax litter trying and failing to get up to go to Laughtale and all the Crossguild weeping and being stupid and maybe even Mihawk being impressed by Buggy trying to will himself to go forward and then Law just walks in and Rooms it away with Buggy's S-Tier luck stat. Of course this does focus Blackbeard on the Cross Guild, because he wants the OP Devilfruit.

Theres a reason why Roger is never shown in Alabasta even though we know Roger took the same route as Luffy through Paradise both times. The reason is that Buggy is a member of the nefertari royal bloodline and they picked him up there. This ALSO makes him a D.

Rocks is silhouetted because he's Dragon's father. Garp adopted him to keep his identity secret when he joined the Marines. The Koby storyline tells you the marines dont recruit from notorious criminals and even their families are barred. The entire secret twist is that Luffy is Rocks' blood. This is why Woop Slap asks "is it his dream or his destiny" to be a pirate and why Garp is so insanely against Luffy being a pirate.

Rogers lesser known apprentice is wildddddd

Buggy is a member of the Big Nose Tribe, who have the latent ability to smell the Scent of All Things.

With that nose buggy is noland's descendant and Shanks with that red hair is calgara's descendant, two friends/enemies, haha.

10:37 Nice Idea but I dont see Berry-Eyed Nami leaving this huge treasure behind. :D

The Rocks theory is really fun. Between the charisma comparison, wild hair, and the stretched smile in the silhouettes similar to how Buggy can smile big, too... It's pretty believable. Plus the timeline all lines up, as well. It's also really in line with how Oda would write Buggy since he's still around, and perfectly wraps up Buggy's character and origin, too. All this time, his luck was really the will of D, and he stumbled ass-backwards through his father's footsteps at every turn. His connections to other great pirates were echoes of his legacy, and he never knew. My hope is that if this is true, Buggy never finds out and is blissfully unaware of his heritage. I love stuff like that, like Hohenheim being the philosopher of legend in FMA and no one in the story ever found out.

Buggy is genuinely a decent fighter with great physical strength, as seen in impel down. He uses the blugori axes like they weigh the same as a piece of paper. He was a fighter equal to shanks as an apprentice on Rogers crew. I think despite him being a joke the vibe is that if he had haki he would be a truly strong fighter. Before haki existed to the audience he was a genuine threat, and only seems like a joke in comparison with the other villains and Luffy. But all he needs is a little haki (which he absolutely does now that his dreams of being pirate king returned) and a devil fruit awakening (also possible). I know nobody likes it, but I'm very convinced that Buggy will be an actual threatening presence end of series. He's an important character. It's not a joke.