P Bass Vs Jazz Bass: is one really BETTER?... Maybe šŸ¤”

Published 2023-03-25
If you had to choose your top Fender bass guitar, which would you choose? They might have come from the same drawing board, but the Jazz and P Bass have some major differences. Both changed the world. But which is the right one for you?

Disclaimer: For any of you recognising these basses - this video was filmed last year before our Treasure Hunt Giveaway. They were part of that prize list and have since been given away. We hope their new owners are enjoying them! šŸ˜œ

===

Video Breakdown:

00:00 - Should you be playing a P Bass or a Jazz Bass?
00:41 - The Precision Bass
01:35 - P bass details
02:31 - P bass neck
04:06 - The P bass' versatility
04:51 - The Jazz Bass
05:52 - The J bass details
06:36 - The J bass pickups
08:55 - How to decide on which to pick for yourself

===

GET MORE BASS TIPS šŸ‘‡
_________________________________________________________________
šŸ™Œ Be the first to know - SUBSCRIBE now ā†’ bit.ly/sub-to-sbl-yt
šŸ”“ Unlock your FREE trial to transform your bass playing ā†’ bit.ly/3fXt4cI


ABOUT SCOTTā€™S BASS LESSONS (SBL)
_________________________________________________________________
As the largest online bass education platform in the world, with an ever-expanding course library and 40,000+ active members, Scottā€™s Bass Lessons (SBL) has everything you need to master the bass, all in one place.

Featuring beginner level bass lessons, engaging courses from expert instructors, step-by-step development curricula, direct feedback on your playing, real-time mentorship from A-list bassists and a thriving and incredibly supportive community, SBL is the perfect platform to uplevel your bass playing, whether youā€™re a total beginner, or an advanced pro-level bassist.

Try SBL Membership today! ā†’ bit.ly/3fXt4cI

RECOMMENDED BASS PLAYLIST
_________________________________________________________________
Catch up with SBL Content youā€™ve missed:
āž”ļø Ā Ā Ā ā€¢Ā SBLĀ FullĀ VideoĀ PlaylistĀ Ā 

Love videos on basses? We've got loads!
āž”ļø Ā Ā Ā ā€¢Ā AllĀ ThingsĀ BassĀ GearĀ Ā 

#bassguitarlessons #pbass #jazzbass

LINKS & OTHER RESOURCES
_________________________________________________________________
Tune in to our Weekly Podcast:
šŸŽ§ sblpodcast.buzzsprout.com/share
Explore our free courses:
šŸŽø freebasscourses.com/
Try our FREE GrooveTrainer App:
šŸ“± scottsbasslessons.com/groove-trainer-app

All Comments (21)
  • I started out on guitar and got serious about bass after my oldest brother Angelo died. Mom wanted me to have his Jazz bass. I got really into bass and even played more gigs on bass than guitar for a while. Itā€™s a way to keep my brother close to me.
  • I started out gigging on Jazz style basses. Loved them. Then I noticed the more professional recording work I did, the more I started gravitating to P basses. Now Iā€™m pretty much full time P bass. I think Jazz basses sound better by themselves, but P basses tend to sound better in the mix. Strange sort of conundrum! Also, P basses help me not overplay with those chunky necks, particularly the vintage style ones I record the most. No wrong answer here :)
  • @Maffy35
    My first bass was a Jazz bass, then bought all sorts of active/fretless fancy ones 5/6 strings until recently I got a p bass. Turns out that's what I was looking for all along
  • @Bubba-zu6yr
    Statistically I donā€™t know the actual breakdown of popularity but in owning a owning my own music shop, I move P-Basses three to one. Itā€™s almost as if the name ā€œJazz Bassā€ scares my clientele to the P-Bass. Nothing scientific, just many years of observations. Good stuff, thank you!
  • @_Peremalfait
    I have to take a minute to appreciate the genius of Leo Fender. His first electric bass guitar was the P-bass. How did he get so much right on his first try?
  • @MFitz12
    When my teen daughter wanted to take up the bass after a few years on the guitar, I got here a Squire PJ bass (P body, jazz bridge pickup combined with P-pass pickup) with a jazz bass style neck. Seemed like a good combo then and still does.
  • @KyleS.1987
    I have both and wouldn't want to give up either of them. Thank you, Leo.
  • Ive been plqying bass for 13 years and always preferred jazz basses until I bought a fender player series p bass 18 months ago. Since then its the only bass i use for practically everything, from gigging to recording it just works.
  • I have both, but so loved the Jazz Bridge pickup that I've come to the conclusion (that many have) that a P/J combination is right for me.
  • @fromquake
    Great video pointing out the differences between the 2 most influential and iconic basses ever made. Note that the 70s jazz basses have the bridge pickup placed closer to the bridge for that brighter, more pingy sound. Itā€™s subtle, but I definitely noticed a difference from my 2010 jazz bass to my current custom build jazz bass with the CBS/70s bridge pickup position.
  • @Macna333
    I have both and play both but I always end up back with the Jazz, my first love.
  • When I started bass I went for a Fender Jazz bass, but have always wondered if I should have went the P-Bass route. Thanks for a great video explaining the difference, I'm happy I went for a Jazz Bass, but tbh I still find the controls for blending the pickups on a Jazz Bass puzzling!
  • There's one important aspect to mention as well. The PBs split coil is humbucking, which is one of the reasons why (pointed by others) it is preferred by technicians (studio/gig). JB single coils need a proper shielding or you will get a lot of hum.
  • @TheLamrith
    Thanks for the great videos you put out! I have been thinking about learning bass, and skimming your YT vids the last few days. I was just watching this comparison while looking at local listings and made a deal on a local P-bass package I am picking up tomorrow based on information in this video.
  • My first bass is a Squier 1975 vintageJazz Bass, and I love it. But sometimes i feel, i need a P Bass too.šŸ˜ Thanks for a video. Greetings from Hungary.šŸ‘
  • @33grinder33
    I started playing a few months ago and faced the same conundrum. I bought a Yamaha TRBX174 with both precision and jazz pick-ups which gives best of both worlds and letā€™s me murder a range of different styles and tunes.
  • For me, I was always convinced that I preferred jazz bass, and for years Iā€™d play them at music stores and never want to take them home. I finally decided to try a precision bass, specifically a PJ precision bass, and I just couldnā€™t put it down. Havenā€™t looked back since.
  • @KngsPwn4
    Great explanation of both the P bass and J bassā€¦thanks!!! I have a P bass and if I played bass full-time I might consider changing to the J bass as I like the increased versatility it offers.
  • @spazianiband
    Congratulations to the Scott channel, always full of news and beautiful things to hear and see, I wouldn't give up my Jazz Bass for anything in the world, I've used many basses for about 45 years and I'm more and more convinced of it, where you connect it it sounds well, he is the absolute prince for me, bye.
  • I have both basses, and personally I prefer the P-bass sound over the J-bass. And I totally agree that the P is a little bit tough than the J, in terms of playability. And TBF, my main bass is a P bass with a J neck, and to me this is the perfect combo.